A 2025 Booklist Editor’s Choice Pick

A 2025 MSTA Reading Circle Best New Books for Missouri Students Reading List Pick (Missouri)

A 2026 Kansas Notable Book

A 2026 Rise: A Feminist Book Project List Pick

A 2026-2027 Volunteer State Book Award Nominee (Tennessee)

★ “Herrman has created a rare kind of book: a twist-filled murder mystery dressed up in leather boots, spurs, and a cowboy hat. . . The writing is compelling and visceral, with a multitude of colorful, complex characters, including the ferocious, canny protagonist. For readers who enjoy a propulsive narrative, this is a special one indeed. —Booklist, starred review

★ “A dark, compelling exploration of Alice’s dreams pitted against men’s demands on her. . . The swiftly paced writing is intriguing, pulsing with danger and desire. . . Full of constant twists and turns of love and terror. . . A very strong first buy.” —School Library Journal, starred review

“An evocative, ferocious exploration of darkness and truth—this one will come at you with a roar and stay with you long after the final page.” —Kerri Maniscalco, #1 New York Times bestselling author of Stalking Jack the Ripper

“Herrman’s sophisticated exploration of the impact of men’s abuse of power are chilling . . . but Belle’s individual strength and continued resistance prove inspirational. The nonlinear timeline enhances the larger-than-life vignettes that are reminiscent of tall tales, maintaining a quick pace and adding tension to each dramatic beat. . . Intense hardship and adventure compellingly intertwine in this Old West feminist journey.” —Kirkus